Electrical automotive troubleshooting

04-23-2019 | 자동차

One of the most rampant electrical maladies showing up in automotive service bays today is the phenomenon known as voltage drop. Left unchecked, voltage drop causes countless unsolved electrical mysteries, especially when it infects the ground side of a circuit. It can also trick you into replacing parts that are not bad.

The more connections and wiring a vehicle has, the more vulnerable the electrical system is to voltage drop.

Practice safe electrical service when containing electrical voltage drop. This means measuring voltage drop before reaching any conclusions. “Voltage dropping” a circuit tells you when the circuit is too restricted to operate a component (e.g., motor, relay, light bulb) or operate it correctly. If the circuit is restricted, repair it and retest. If there is no restriction and the component still does not run or run correctly, then replace the component.

Example of voltage drop

In this example, when a wire falls off or a connection breaks, current stops flowing, and the voltage drops to zero. The starter motor would turn off or a headlight would go out.

Symptoms of voltage drop

Often confusing and contradictory, electrical voltage drop symptoms vary according to the circuit’s job and the severity of the voltage drop.

  • Inoperative electrical parts
  • Sluggish, lazy electrical devices
  • Erratic, intermittent devices
  • Devices that work sluggishly or erratically during periods of high electrical loads
  • Excessive radio interference or noises in the radio
  • Damaged throttle or transmission cables or linkage
  • Repeated throttle or transmission cable failures
  • Damaged drivetrain parts
  • Engine or transmission performance complaints
  • No-starts or hard starts
  • High sensor or computer voltages
  • Erratic engine or transmission computer performance
  • False trouble codes in the memory of any on-board computer
  • Premature or repeated A/C compressor clutch failure

This symptom list brings up several points.

  1. Visual inspections miss most cases of electrical voltage drop. You usually can’t see the corrosion inside a connection or the damaged wire that is causing the problem.
  2. Ground-side voltage drop, a commonly overlooked cause of electrical trouble, can cause most of these symptoms. Any circuit or component is only as good as its ground.
  3. The more sophisticated electrical systems become, the more important their grounds are. The number of electrical components has increased rapidly and most do not have separate ground wires. Instead, these devices are grounded to the engine or body. Rust, grease, vibration and/or careless repairs often restrict the circuit from the engine/body back to the battery.
  4. Many components, such as engine sensors, share a common ground. Therefore, a bad ground complicates diagnosis because it affects several components at once.
  5. Some shop manuals and diagnostic charts or fault trees recommend checking grounds last. It is much quicker to check ground circuits before you climb that fault tree.
  6. It is quicker and smarter to routinely check a circuit’s voltage drop than it is to memorize long lists of symptoms. If experience has taught us nothing else, it is that chasing symptoms is no substitute for routine and thorough voltage drop testing.

Experience has taught us other reasons to check voltage drop first. Voltage drop, usually on the ground side, causes inaccurate or bizarre digital multimeter readings and oscilloscope patterns. Moreover, when you connect a digital multimeter or scope to a system with bad grounds, the test equipment itself can create a good substitute ground, depending on the instrument’s impedance. If impedance is low enough, this can be frustrating—if your equipment is connected, the circuit works, and you can’t find anything wrong.

Basic procedures

Whenever an electrical problem gives you fits, take a deep breath and think of the basic electrical building block: the series circuit. No matter how complicated a system is, you can always simplify it to smaller series of circuits. Then, inspect each circuit for voltage drop.

Electrical circuit with kink

In an electrical circuit, electrical pressure (voltage or volts) pushes electrical volume (current or amps) through the circuit, operating a load. The load may be a computer, a motor, a lamp, a relay or other device. Electrical pressure (voltage) is used up operating the load. Therefore, voltage falls to about zero on the ground side, but current keeps flowing toward the battery. Because the voltage in a healthy ground circuit should be about zero, some technicians call it ground zero.

Ground-side voltage drop hurts load performance and causes a voltage reading at the ground side of the load.

Resistance—Restriction

Excessive resistance on an electrical circuit can cause a restriction in current flow. Bad connections and broken or undersized wires act like a pipe with a kink, restricting current flow. Restricting current flow anywhere—hot side or ground side—hurts the performance of the load. The effect on the load is hard to predict because it varies with the severity of the restriction. For example, the motor in a restricted circuit may stop working or just run slower than normal.

A restricted circuit can cause an a/c compressor clutch to slip and prematurely burn out. A computer on a restricted circuit may shut off or work erratically. When corrosion, loose connections or other types of resistance restrict a circuit, volts and amps both drop. If volts drop, amps drop too. That is why when you find a voltage drop in a connection or cable, you know the connection or cable is restricted.

Electrical circuit with broken wire

Look at the circuits in our drawings and remember two critical points:

  1. A free-flowing ground side is as important as a free-flowing hot side.
  2. A ground-side restriction is the only thing that causes voltage readings greater than 0 to 0.1V in any ground circuit.

A broken ground wire totally blocks current flow, shuts off the load and causes the ground side of the load to read system voltage.

Voltage drop tests

Electrical voltage drop varies according to current flow. Unless you operate the circuit so current flows through it, you cannot measure voltage drop. Because a digital multimeter’s battery cannot supply the current that normally flows through most circuits, digital multimeter tests usually cannot detect restrictions as accurately as a voltage drop test.

Open-circuit problems such as broken or disconnected wires or connections stop current flow. After you fix an open circuit, switch the circuit on again and check for lingering voltage drop. Until you get current flowing and check the circuit again, you cannot know if the entire circuit is healthy.

Although resistance-free connections, wires and cables would be ideal, most of them will contain at least some voltage drop. If your manuals do not list voltage drop values, use the following as maximum limits:

  • 0.00V across a connection
  • 0.20V across a wire or cable
  • 0.30V across a switch
  • 0.10V at a ground

Because most computer circuits operate in the milliamp range, they do not tolerate voltage drop as well as other circuits do. Note that a milliamp is one-thousandth (0.001) amp. The recommended working limit is 0.10V-drop across low-current wires and switches. Testing low-current circuits also requires a high-impedance (10-megohm) digital multimeter. A low-impedance digital multimeter may load a low-current circuit so much that it gives an incorrect reading or no reading at all. Most professional-grade digital multimeters have 10-megohm input impedance. Using a digital multimeter is the fastest way to accurately measure voltage drop. If the digital multimeter you own does not have auto-ranging capability, use a low-voltage (0 to 1V) scale for voltage drop testing. Remember that test lights are not accurate enough to diagnose electrical voltage drop and can damage most computer circuits.

Quick ground tests

Because ground circuit voltage drop can cause most of the symptoms listed earlier, consider adopting this new work habit: test grounds first. Before you do a tune-up, check out electrical problems, or test a starting, charging, ABS, or air conditioning system, routinely test the engine and body grounds. Connect your digital multimeter between the engine and negative battery terminal. Safely disarm the ignition and crank the engine for a few seconds, or if your multimeter has a data recording function it will capture the reading in as little as 100 milliseconds.

If the voltage drop is excessive, repair the engine ground circuit and retest. Note that on some ignition systems without a distributor, the simplest way to prevent the engine from starting during the ground test is to pull the fuel pump fuse. Next, connect the digital multimeter between the negative battery terminal and the vehicle’s firewall. Then start the engine and switch on the major electrical accessories. If there is too much voltage drop, then fix the body ground and retest.

Once the engine and body grounds are within limits, proceed with your diagnosis. Do not be surprised if fixing these grounds solves the car’s problems. The fact that a vehicle passes the body ground test does not mean you can safely ground your digital multimeter wherever you want to. Some technicians have run in circles for hours because their digital multimeters were not well grounded. For safe electrical service, make yourself a 20- or 30-foot jumper wire with an alligator clip on each end, allowing you to test an electrical fuel pump, lighting system or ABS computer in the rear of the vehicle by grounding your digital multimeter to the battery with the jumper wire.

Computer ground kinks

Because computer circuits operate on such low current, the standard ground tests may not reveal a marginal ground on an on-board computer. Before you condemn any on-board computer, check its grounds first. Operate the computer system and back-probe each computer ground terminal. If you measure anything greater than 0.10V, trace that ground circuit and locate the problem.

Sometimes computer grounds are connected to a spot where they are easily disturbed or prone to corrosion, such as a thermostat-housing bolt. Computer connector terminals can also corrode. Removing the connector and spraying the terminals with electrical cleaner may be all it takes to eliminate the voltage drop.

Experience shows that as little as 0.30V on a computer ground terminal can cause trouble. Before pinpointing that with an electronic test light, remember that a traditional test light pulls too much current and can damage the computer. Poor computer and/or sensor grounds can cause higher-than-normal sensor voltages and false trouble codes. In many cases, the bad ground prevents the computer or sensor from pulling a voltage signal down to or near ground zero. Accessing the computer to check grounds may be a hassle, however, mistakenly replacing expensive sensors and computers is a bigger hassle.

Voltage loss between battery and load

Connect a digital multimeter across any part of a circuit to directly read the voltage drop across that wire, cable, switch or connection. In this example, one digital multimeter would display the voltage loss between the battery and the load, the other would show the voltage loss from the ground side of the load to the battery.

Body ground gremlins

Keep your eyes peeled for missing body grounds. If someone else worked on the vehicle, they may have forgotten to reconnect body ground wires or cables. Remember that when the body ground is restricted current tries to find another route back to the battery. The easiest alternate route may be through the transmission shift cable or the throttle cable. Not only can this current weld the cable together, it also can pit or erode bushings and bearings inside the transmission or wheel bearings.

If you find the insulation on the body ground wire is burnt or blistered, you can bet that starter current overheated the wire. When the engine ground is restricted, starter current tries to return to the battery through the body ground circuit. Experience shows that if the body ground circuit can not handle the current load, the customer may not notice the problem right away.

Under periods of heavy current flow, a restricted body ground may hamper or shut off a component. For example, turn signals have been known to stop blinking when the driver steps on the brake pedal. Testing confirmed that a restricted body ground choked off the turn signals. The ground could not handle the current from the turn signals and the brake lights at the same time.

Safe service

Practicing safe electrical service helps you solve electrical problems quicker and more profitably than guessing and swapping parts out. Put your digital multimeter to work, wiping out electrical voltage drop, today. It is the responsible thing to do.

Get the Fluke Newsletter